Games Like The Innsmouth Case (2026)

Loved The Innsmouth Case? Here are 12 similar games worth playing next — ranked by critic and player scores, each with live price comparison from trusted key stores like Eneba and Kinguin so you find the cheapest place to buy. Prefer the original? Compare The Innsmouth Case prices →

#1
MiSide
Shared: Multiple Endings, Short Playthrough
The dating-sim wrapper is bait, and MiSide knows it. What starts as idle chores with an anime girl becomes a genre-hopping psychological horror that two developers built better than most studios manage with a full team.
from €9.46-37%·Compare prices →
#2
Undertale
92
Shared: Multiple Endings, Short Playthrough
A 6-8 hour RPG that quietly asks whether you actually need to kill anything, then spends its entire runtime making you feel the answer either way.
from €1.12·Compare prices →
#3
POSTAL 2
59
Shared: Dark Comedy
POSTAL 2 is a gleefully unhinged open-world sandbox where every mundane errand can spiral into a catastrophic firefight - if you let it.
from €0.64·Compare prices →
#4
Hollow Knight: Silksong
90
Shared: Multiple Endings
Six years of memes and broken promises evaporated the moment I dropped into Pharloom. Hornet is a razor-sharp upgrade in every direction, and Team Cherry somehow delivered on the hype.
from €5.22·Compare prices →
#5
OMORI
87
Shared: Multiple Endings
Pastel sketchbook exteriors hiding a gut-punch story about grief, guilt, and four years of a locked bedroom door. One of the rare indie RPGs where the mechanics and the narrative are actually saying the same thing.
from €5.81·Compare prices →

More games like The Innsmouth Case

Never overpay for your next favourite game

Get price-drop alerts and the best new deals straight to your inbox. No spam.

Weekly roundup. Unsubscribe anytime.

12 Games Like The Innsmouth Case (2026) | GamerScout