Games Like Forgive Me Father (2026)

Shared: Atmospheric Horror

Four players, zero weapons, one shared panic attack: if your friend group can handle grotesque Cold War experiments and a sanity meter that actively tries to break you, this one earns its place on the Saturday night roster.

Shared: Sanity Mechanic

Four friends, one haunted building, a spirit box, and someone who absolutely will not stop talking near the Yokai. If that sentence sounds fun to you, you already know the answer.

Shared: Sanity Mechanic

Crash a plane, lose your son, then spend 30+ hours building spike traps and slowly losing your mind to cannibals. Solo or with up to 8 friends online, this one earns its Metacritic 83.

Shared: Sanity Mechanic

Surviving alone was already brutal - surviving with friends who make catastrophic decisions is another beast entirely. A deep, unforgiving co-op survival game that rewards patience, preparation, and someone on the team who knows what a Science Machine actually does.

Shared: Atmospheric Horror

Crash-land on an ocean planet, then spend dozens of hours too scared to go deeper, but going anyway. Subnautica is survival-crafting with genuine dread and beauty.