Games Like Nightmare Reaper (2026)

Loved Nightmare Reaper? Here are 11 similar games worth playing next — ranked by critic and player scores, each with live price comparison from trusted key stores like Eneba and Kinguin so you find the cheapest place to buy. Prefer the original? Compare Nightmare Reaper prices →

#1
POSTAL 2
59
Shared: Boomer Shooter
POSTAL 2 is a gleefully unhinged open-world sandbox where every mundane errand can spiral into a catastrophic firefight - if you let it.
from €0.64·Compare prices →
#2
Hotline Miami
85
Shared: Synth Soundtrack
Few games from 2012 still live rent-free in people's heads the way this one does. Brutal, precise, and stranger than it has any right to be.
from €1.80·Compare prices →
#3
Cult of the Lamb
82
Shared: Roguelite
Roguelite dungeon runs meet colony micromanagement in a package that keeps pulling you back for 'just one more crusade' - and now with local co-op too.
from €7.37·Compare prices →
#4
Vampire Survivors
86
Shared: Roguelite
Forget the genre label. Once you crack the weapon evolution system, thirty minutes vanish and then another thirty, and then it's 2 AM and you're theorycrafting a Bloody Tear build in your head.
from €1.99·Compare prices →
#5
ULTRAKILL
Shared: Boomer Shooter
One solo developer built the most aggressively joyful FPS on PC, and 100,000 Steam reviewers gave it a 98% approval rating. If that doesn't make you curious, nothing will.
from €5.93·Compare prices →

More games like Nightmare Reaper

Never overpay for your next favourite game

Get price-drop alerts and the best new deals straight to your inbox. No spam.

Weekly roundup. Unsubscribe anytime.