Farming Simulator 25 is already a niche within a niche - a slow-burn agricultural sandbox where you genuinely care about soil moisture and crop rotation schedules. The Highlands Fishing Expansion tries to broaden that loop by dropping players into a Scottish-flavored setting, adding fishing mechanics alongside the usual tractor wrangling. On paper that sounds like a reasonable extension of the sim's leisurely pace. In practice, the execution is uneven enough that 46% of the Steam reviewers came away disappointed, which is not a number you can wave away. The core of the expansion is, predictably, fishing. You cast lines, manage catches, and presumably fold the income back into your farm operation. For a sim audience that already tolerates menus and spreadsheets, the idea of adding a secondary economic activity centered on freshwater fishing in misty Highland terrain has real appeal. The Scottish aesthetic - rolling hills, moody skies, the kind of scenery that makes you want a cup of tea - is Farming Simulator doing what it does well visually. GIANTS Software has a track record of constructing believable rural environments, and there is no reason to think the Highlands map itself is the problem. The problems, based on community feedback, cluster around depth and value. Fishing mechanics in farming sims live or die on whether they feel like a genuine system or a feature checkbox, and the Mixed score suggests too many buyers feel they got the latter. If you are the type who logs 200-hour campaigns and optimizes every supply chain, you will notice pretty quickly whether the fishing layer has enough variables to stay interesting - lure types, fish behavior tied to weather or time of day, market pricing for different species, that kind of thing. Slim decision trees in a DLC attached to a decision-heavy base game feel especially thin by contrast. The base game's mod ecosystem is a legitimate strength for longevity, but mod support for expansion content tends to lag, so do not assume the community will paper over any gaps immediately. Who this is actually for: players who have already sunk serious hours into Farming Simulator 25 and want a new map with a different activity rhythm, without expecting that activity to rival the agricultural systems in complexity. If Scotland and fishing are aesthetically appealing to you and you are not expecting a full-blown fishing sim, there is probably enough here to justify an afternoon session or two. Newcomers to the franchise should absolutely start with the base game before considering any expansion, and veterans burned out on the core loop probably will not find enough novelty here to reignite things. Diego, Scout Team