Games Like Family Mysteries: Poisonous Promises (2026)
Loved Family Mysteries: Poisonous Promises? Here are 6 similar games worth playing next — ranked by critic and player scores, each with live price comparison from trusted key stores like Eneba and Kinguin so you find the cheapest place to buy. Prefer the original? Compare Family Mysteries: Poisonous Promises prices →
#1The Henry Stickmin Collection
Shared: Short Playthrough
Six remastered Newgrounds classics plus a brand-new finale, all built around the joyful premise that dying is the whole point. If you missed the flash-game era, this is the gentlest possible re-entry.
from €6.31-55%·Compare prices →
#2Outer Wilds
85Shared: Mystery
Pure curiosity is the only currency that matters here, no combat, no skill trees, just a handcrafted solar system full of secrets and a 22-minute clock before the sun wipes everything out.
from €6.27-55%·Compare prices →
#3MiSide
Shared: Short Playthrough
The dating-sim wrapper is bait, and MiSide knows it. What starts as idle chores with an anime girl becomes a genre-hopping psychological horror that two developers built better than most studios manage with a full team.
from €9.46-37%·Compare prices →
#4Firewatch
81Shared: Mystery
Four to seven hours alone in the Wyoming wilderness with a walkie-talkie and a mystery that burns brighter than it lands - if that sounds like your kind of evening, keep reading.
from €4.59·Compare prices →#5
South Park: The Stick of Truth (uncut)
85Shared: Short Playthrough
Obsidian's love letter to South Park is a surprisingly solid RPG wrapped in the show's most unhinged humor. New Kid in town, ready to rule the school.
from €7.51·Compare prices →
More games like Family Mysteries: Poisonous Promises
Never overpay for your next favourite game
Get price-drop alerts and the best new deals straight to your inbox. No spam.
Weekly roundup. Unsubscribe anytime.