Toby: The Secret Mine

My first hour with Toby: The Secret Mine felt like settling into a quiet room someone had half-decorated. The silhouette aesthetic, the glowing white eyes, the ambient creak of a world that wants you dead, all of it arrives wrapped in obvious affection for Playdead's Limbo. But Lukas Navratil built this entirely alone, and that handmade quality shows in ways both charming and frustrating. It is a one-person passion project wearing its inspirations openly, and I respect that honesty even when the seams show. The setup is wordless and immediate. Your small horned creature witnesses a kidnapping, and off you go across 21 side-scrolling levels spanning forests, caves, a blizzard zone, and the titular mine. The core loop is classic: read the environment, push blocks, flip switches, time your leaps, die, learn, repeat. Where Toby carves its own small space is in the colour. Unlike Limbo's grey monochrome, the backgrounds here shift through warm desert oranges, blinding snow-white, and deep cavern blues, with each palette quietly telegraphing the mood of the zone you are crossing. Bright spikes and red hazards pop against the dark silhouette foreground, which functions as a subtle danger-reading system. There are also 26 captive friends hidden in bird cages throughout the levels, tucked into alcoves and behind breakable floors, giving completionists a secondary layer to hunt. A mine-cart sequence near the end shifts the pace entirely, and a binary ending choice lands with mild weight if you have been paying attention to the atmosphere. The problems are real and worth knowing before you commit. The protagonist moves with a deliberate, heavy slowness that some players will find contemplative and others will find maddening. More critically, the difficulty in the back half leans on trial-and-error deaths rather than readable design: traps spring from darkness with no visual warning, certain breakable floors can only be detected by a subtle audio cue, and some collision logic misfires in ways that feel like bugs rather than design. Puzzles in the first half are almost too gentle, involving straightforward block-pushing and lever sequences, then the game abruptly spikes in the latter levels without the mechanical vocabulary to support that jump. The runtime sits around two to three hours at most, and replay value beyond collectible hunting is thin. For who is this? Honestly, it is for the player who has already finished Limbo and Inside, who wants something lighter in tone and shorter in commitment, and who can forgive a solo developer's rough edges in exchange for a genuinely atmospheric soundscape and some pretty background art. The audio in particular deserves a mention: moody ambient melodies, layered environmental sound design, and textural effects that make the world feel tactile in a way the visuals alone cannot manage. If you are coming here as your first exposure to the silhouette platformer genre, go to Limbo first. If you are coming back for seconds with low expectations and an appreciation for small, handcrafted work, Toby has something quiet and genuine to offer.

Kai · Scout Team

Indie & narrative

Be the first to comment on Toby: The Secret Mine.