Band of Defenders

I kept thinking about Killing Floor 2 while poking around Band of Defenders, and not in a flattering way for the smaller title. The concept is legitimately interesting: a four-player co-op FPS where you alternate between a build phase - placing barricades, upgrading turrets, laying minefields - and a combat phase where you hold the line against escalating waves of mutants and raiders. Each session runs roughly 20-30 minutes, the boss shows up at the end of the last wave, and in theory that tight loop should be snappy enough to sustain repeat play. In theory. The shooting itself is serviceable. The game ships with over 30 craftable weapons, ranging from standard assault rifles and grenade launchers through to laser and tesla rifles. Headshots deal triple damage, iron sights blur the background in a way that feels deliberate rather than cheap, and some of the heavier mutant types - armored elites, kamikazes, EMP-specialists that shut down your turrets - do add real pressure to the combat phase. The building side offers four turret types, three barricade variants, plus utility structures like gun nests. On paper that is a respectable toolbox for an indie budget. The problem is that the depth promised by those numbers never materializes. Build, shoot, repeat. The strategic layer stays shallow across all four difficulty settings, and the handful of maps (three or four total) cycle fast enough that you're seeing the same sightlines before the end of your first session. The progression system is where things get genuinely frustrating. Gear unlocks are tied to loot crates earned through leveling, which means your turret upgrade options and craftable weapon pool are gated behind RNG. On harder difficulties this stops being an annoyance and starts being a wall - the game's own balance demands equipment that the loot system may simply not hand you. Optimization is reportedly acceptable, so at least frames stay stable while you grind, but a game breaking wave-spawn bug has been documented where a wave fails to complete, forcing a full restart and wiping match progress. The real dealbreaker heading into 2026 is the playerbase. Peak concurrent players hit 240 on launch day in April 2018 and has been functionally zero for years. Matchmaking with strangers is not a realistic option. The solo experience is hollow - the wave formula needs coordinated players splitting build duties and covering flanks to generate any real tension. If you don't have two or three friends already interested and willing to buy in together, this game has nothing to offer you. It is co-op infrastructure without a co-op community. Fred, Scout Team