The Suicide of Rachel Foster

My honest first reaction to the Timberline Hotel was something close to reverence. ONE-O-ONE GAMES built a mountain lodge that breathes - corridors lit by weak winter light, every door a small act of courage, the whole structure humming with a sense that something terrible happened here and the walls have decided not to tell you yet. For the first half of this roughly four-to-five-hour walking game, that atmosphere is worth the price of admission on its own. You play as Nicole Wilson, returning to her family's abandoned Montana hotel in 1993 to value it ahead of a sale. A snowstorm traps her inside, and her only company is Irving Crawford, a FEMA agent she reaches through a chunky period cellphone. The Nicole-Irving dynamic is the game's emotional spine, and the voice performances give it genuine warmth. Their exchanges start guarded, then thaw through banter, landing somewhere tender - comparisons to Firewatch are unavoidable and mostly fair. Mechanically, the game is light: you follow waypoint markers on a hotel map, gather items like a screwdriver or a generator switch, and occasionally use acquired tools including a Polaroid camera used as a flash-light in a pitch-dark sequence, a mechanically powered flashlight, and a parabolic microphone for picking up distant sounds. Chapters are short, auto-saving at the end of each in-game day. There are no inventory puzzles to speak of, and backtracking fills more time than it probably should. Where things fracture is the story's second half. The central mystery involves Nicole's father and his relationship with a teenage girl named Rachel - the game openly signals it intends to explore child abuse, grief, and predatory behavior, and the developers consulted professionals during development to handle those themes responsibly. Whether they succeeded is the genuine fault line in the game's critical reception. A significant number of critics argued the narrative ends up framing the abuser sympathetically, giving Rachel almost no voice of her own, and building toward a climax that places players inside a suicide attempt without sufficient emotional groundwork to justify it. Others found the tension earned and the conclusion impactful. The Metacritic score lands at 72 and OpenCritic puts the critic recommendation rate at around 34 percent - those two numbers living in the same sentence tells you everything about how divided the response has been. What holds up unambiguously is the sound design. Creaking floorboards, wind pressing against the building, doors shifting somewhere you are not - the Timberline sounds lonely in a way that few games achieve without relying on jump scares. The sparse score appears only when plot pivots demand it, which is exactly the right choice. That restraint, that willingness to let silence do structural work, is the fingerprint of a team that understood at least one dimension of their craft deeply. The hotel itself - its basement, its guest rooms holding small mysteries, its crawl spaces that feel genuinely threatening - is among the better-designed single locations in recent narrative games. It is the story that divides, not the place. If you have a high tolerance for morally uncomfortable subject matter and can engage critically with a narrative that asks you to do some of the ethical heavy lifting it fails to do itself, the Timberline Hotel is worth a visit. If you need the game to clearly condemn what it depicts, you will likely leave frustrated. A sequel, The Fading of Nicole Wilson, was announced in late 2024 - so this is also, retroactively, an origin story.

Kai · Scout Team

Indie & narrative

Be the first to comment on The Suicide of Rachel Foster.