PT Boats: Knights of the Sea

I have a soft spot for simulations that try something genuinely different, and the torpedo-boat side of WW2 naval warfare is about as underexplored as it gets in PC gaming. That said, spending time with PT Boats: Knights of the Sea is a lesson in a concept that outpaces its execution by a wide margin. The pitch is legitimately interesting: you command small, fragile Motor Torpedo Boats for the British, German, or Soviet fleets in the European theater, not the Pacific that most players would expect. You cycle between a first-person gunner stance, a third-person boat view, and an overhead 2D tactical map that lets you issue orders to your whole squadron. On paper, that layered control scheme sounds like the best of action-sim and RTS. In practice, constantly jumping between four distinct view modes creates real role confusion. Are you a gunner? A boat captain? A squadron commander? The game never convincingly answers that, and the interface buckles under the question. The campaign structure is five themed episodes of five missions each, with bonus missions unlocking after completion. Mission types cover interception runs, escort duty, rescue ops, and landing commandos, which is a decent spread on paper. The problem is that every scenario is scripted and linear, with enemy forces appearing at the same coordinates every run. There is no dynamic campaign, no random encounter generator, and critically no mid-mission save. That last point is punishing when missions drag long and technical glitches, phantom boat outlines, disappearing smoke effects, and the occasional DX10 startup crash on modern Windows, cut your session short and send you back to the beginning. The AI is inconsistent too: scripted enough to be predictable on repeat runs, yet passive enough that veteran sim players will not feel seriously pressed in open combat. Where the game does earn points is in the physical feel of the boats themselves. The speed and tight turning radius of an MTB are well simulated, and lining up a torpedo run against a destroyer while zigzagging to stay out of its gun arc is genuinely tense. You can man machine guns, operate the torpedo director, lay smoke, and manage hull, engine, and fire damage through a repair panel. Night missions with searchlights are a high point. The ship models are detailed, wakes and wave motion are solid, and sinking animations land with appropriate drama. Guns slew at a measured, realistic rate and hold their position when you step off the trigger, which gives direct-fire combat a weight that many arcade-adjacent titles skip entirely. Multiplayer offers deathmatch and team deathmatch modes for up to fifteen players, but the community is effectively gone and finding a populated server is not a realistic expectation in 2024. For strategy and sim players specifically: this is not a deep decision-making game. There is no fleet management meta, no tech progression, no refit system. The RTS layer is light enough to classify as a convenience tool rather than a genuine strategic mode. The mod ecosystem is sparse and the absence of a mission editor, which was reportedly discussed but never delivered, kills long-term replay value dead. If your benchmark is something like Silent Hunter or Dangerous Waters, this sits several tiers below in terms of systemic depth. If your benchmark is an accessible action-sim with a historically underserved subject, a short but varied set of mission objectives, and a forgiving enough difficulty scaler to make it approachable for newcomers, there is a narrow audience that will get a couple of solid evenings out of it before the scripted repetition sets in.

Diego · Scout Team

Strategy & simulation

Be the first to comment on PT Boats: Knights of the Sea.